Problems I like: Problem set 9, problem 5: combinatorial proof I'd like to see a combinatorial proof on the exam. This can be a/the problem where they write a proof logically. It need not be too difficult, but I really feel these problems are *very* conceptual, which is a good thing. In particular, I dislike counting problems where they count something like, "the number of hands which have 2 hearts but only one queen". Another thing we can do with combinatorial proofs is to give a combinatorial proof, and ask them to fill in the "equation A = equation B" part. A problem idea: We could mix counting with asymptotics. We could say: show that the (# of something) = O(blah). Show that it is not Theta(blah). A problem idea: We could mix graph theory with logical quantifiers, asking them to give a logical definition of independent set, vertex cover, coloring, etc. In-Class Problems Week 13, Friday, Problem 2: We could give them the Von-Neumann trick. Ask them what's the expected number of flips before we get a bit out, as well as show that it gives unbiased bits.