p10: part b typo: ...was within c of the actual value r (should be b, right, like in part a?). p11: the problem needs more parts: such as what is the expected length of try what is the expected number of tries (for both parts). p12: paths are simple paths? (no cycles?) if not then I don't see why the tree paths are not O(n). p13-14-15: I don't like. 13 and 15 are similar to the pizza problem (counting mistakes). 14 is repetition of exam 2 with the new parts being even more confusing and hard to grade. General opinion: I see very few problems on the untested material namely: p1: induction p2: state machines, graphs. p3: series p4: counting p5: counting p6: probability p7: expectation p8: counting, prob, little expectation p9: prob p10: sampling p11: expectation p12: graphs, orders p13: counting p14: counting, pigeonhole p15: counting Counting wins with 6/15! We don't have a problem covering anything about variance, Markov, Chebychev, Chernoff. 3.3/15 problems have something relevant to the material not covered by the first two exams. I thought Albert said that the final would be 50% biased towards the later material. Also I didn't see game-trees and structural induction. We didn't test this either. So, given these problems I would see something like: p12 (maybe a couple of extra parts, this problem could be done in 2 minutes). p1 p2 p3 p5 game-trees, pay-trees, etc p6 p7 p8 p9 p10 p11 (if fixed) some bound problem, like the spider in-class problem